The Real-Life Boogeyman: Albert Fish in 1920s New York

The Real-Life Boogeyman: Albert Fish in 1920s New York

June 25, 2026 · 13 min

About this episode

This episode explores the disturbing case of Albert Fish and the disappearance of Grace Budd in 1920s New York.

The Real-Life Boogeyman: Albert Fish in 1920s New York In 1928 New York City, ten-year-old Grace Budd walks out of her family’s Manhattan apartment with a soft-spoken “farmer” named Frank Howard and disappears, pulling her parents, detectives, and eventually a courtroom into one of the most disturbing homicide investigations in American history. The search for Grace exposes a pattern of missing children, a mild-mannered house painter named Hamilton “Albert” Fish, and a criminal profile that collides with questions of insanity, responsibility, and what justice looks like when the suspect looks like somebody’s grandfather instead of a monster. In this episode, we walk slowly and carefully through Albert Fish’s life, from a brutal orphanage childhood to the day he knocks on the Budd family’s door, and we sit with the human moments around him: the parents who just want their kid to get a job, the kids playing in city hallways, and the detective who will not let this case go. It is a heavy story, but told like a late-night conversation with a friend, with room for context, a little observational humor where it fits, and a focus on the people rather than just the headlines. 🔔…

More episodes of 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories podcast page.