About this episode

This episode explores the case of Marcus Toney, who was a victim of identity theft and a deadly betrayal that led to his tragic demise.

CASE FILE [EPISODE #17 | Set it Off THE SPIRIT OF THE EPISODE • The Pour: Return to Sender • The ingredients: Dark Spiced Rum, Bitter Campari, Spicy Ginger Beer • The Vibe: A bitter and intense pour with a sudden volatile kick that mirrors the shock of a package arriving at a doorstep, masking a lethal betrayal underneath the surface. THE SUBJECT • Name: Marcus Toney • Date of Incident: February 16, 2000 • Location: Chicago, Illinois (South Side) • Status: Solved THE TIMELINE • Early 2000: Marcus Toney's estranged wife, Lisa, and her secret lover, Sienky Lallemand, steal Marcus's identity to run up over $200,000 in fraudulent debt. • February 2000: Marcus discovers the massive identity theft and prepares to alert the police, unknowingly triggering his wife and her lover's deadly backup plan. • February 16, 2000: The Last Known Sighting. Marcus receives and opens what looks like a gift-wrapped package delivered right to his home; the booby-trapped pipe bombs inside detonate instantly. EVIDENCE LOCKER (Visuals & Links) • The Map: [ South Side, Chicago, IL ] • The "Deep Dive" Source: > Killer Relationships with Faith Jenkins: Season 4 Episode 6- Seduced & Swindled &gt…

More episodes of A Sip Of Redrum

• FL Friday: Exes and Ambushes · July 17, 2026 · 36 min
• The Taillight That Caught a Serial Killer · July 2, 2026 · 39 min

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the A Sip Of Redrum podcast page.