Cardinals counterintuitive holiday shopping list could leave a hole in tradition

About this episode

The episode discusses the Cardinals' unconventional holiday shopping list and the implications of recent player trades.

There should be ballads written about Willson Contreras' brief time with the Cardinals. From his arrival as the All-Star eager for the challenge of following Yadier Molina, to that weird week when he took fly balls in left field and stopped catching, to the injuries and fractures and ultimately his move to first base, out from behind home plate without skipping a beat at the plate. Contreras brought both joy and fury to the Cardinals' lineup and clubhouse, and at some point his absence will be felt by the teammates who remain. But he won't be a alone. In a brand new Best Podcast in Baseball, recorded on Christmas Eve, Post-Dispatch editor Nathan Mills and baseball writer Derrick Goold discuss the Cardinals' counterintuitive shopping list for the holidays and what is missing from it and possibly from the clubhouse during his reboot of an organization. The Cardinals traded a starter (Sonny Gray) only to sign a starter (Dustin May) a few weeks later; they traded a right-handed bat from the middle of the order (Contreras) only to suggest a few hours later that they would now look for a right-handed bat to add to the roster. The Cardinals are swapping All-Stars for pitching depth and…

People in this episode

Host: Nathan Mills

Guest: Derrick Goold

Topics covered

• Cardinals
• holiday shopping
• baseball trades
• team dynamics
• leadership
• player transitions

Keywords

• Willson Contreras
• Sonny Gray
• Dustin May
• Cardinals
• baseball trades
• leadership
• holiday shopping

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Cardinals, St. Louis Post-Dispatch

More episodes of Best Podcast in Baseball

• A conversation with NLBM president Bob Kendrick: Storytelling's power to inspire baseball with its past · June 8, 2026 · 42 min
• 101 life lessons from the dugout and a few extra from the CBA negotiation room · June 5, 2026 · 52 min
• The seams that bind St. Louis baseball and the history of the game itself: A Glove Story · June 3, 2026 · 52 min
• Both humbled by Brewers, Cardinals and Cubs clash for 1st time in series vital for hosts · May 29, 2026 · 1h 13m
• Central Casting: What role will Cardinals play in making the division a real race? · May 22, 2026 · 57 min
• Tarps off! BPIB is back on: Have Cardinals found their voice as a contender? · May 19, 2026 · 1h 10m