Why Nothing Works: Robber Barons, Algorithms & Governing AI
About this episode
Marc Dunkelman discusses the historical parallels between 19th-century railroad power struggles and contemporary issues surrounding algorithms and AI governance.
In this episode, Historian and author Marc Dunkelman to explain why the 19th-century fight over railroad power is the exact fight we're about to have over algorithms and AI. Drawing on his acclaimed book Why Nothing Works: Who Killed Progress — and How to Bring It Back (a Best Book of the Year in the Financial Times and The Economist), Marc unpacks the two competing tools America has always used against concentrated power — antitrust vs. regulation — and why our government's "endemic diffusion of authority" now means nobody can decide anything, from congestion pricing to clean-energy transmission lines to AI safety. CHAPTERS 04:52 — When private projects come back to the public: Warp Speed, DARPA, CHIPS 08:55 — Two ways to fight concentrated power: break them up vs. regulate 10:52 — Railroads, island communities & the birth of regulation 12:29 — The railroad = algorithm parallel 20:33 — Why nothing gets built: the diffusion of authority 27:30 — "A voice without a veto" and the AI moment 32:53 — Where should government draw the line on new tech? 37:20 — Dunkelman the pragmatist: there is no simple answer 38:21 — Where math and AI can genuinely help public policy 40:46 — The…
More episodes of Breaking Math Podcast
- Can Math Save Journalism?: Julia Angwin on Proof, Power, and Amazon's Algorithm
- The Proof in the Code: How Lean Is Quietly Rewriting Trust in Math (w/ Kevin Hartnett)
Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Breaking Math Podcast podcast page.