Reconciliation or Retreat? The Church and Indigenous Identity

Reconciliation or Retreat? The Church and Indigenous Identity

February 17, 2026 · 1h 7m

About this episode

This episode discusses the Vatican's return of Indigenous artifacts and explores deeper themes of reconciliation and cultural identity with Dr. Ashley Frawley.

When the Vatican returned 62 Indigenous artifacts to Canada, many saw it as a gesture of reconciliation. But was something deeper being communicated? In this wide-ranging and provocative episode of Catholic in America, Jason Adkins speaks with sociologist and First Nations member Dr. Ashley Frawley about cultural identity, trauma narratives, missionary history, and the universal claim of Catholicism. Drawing on her Compact Magazine essay, “Are We Not Catholics Too?”, Dr. Frawley challenges th...

More episodes of Catholic in America

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Catholic in America podcast page.