The Secret to Bakery-Style Chocolate Walnut Chip Cookies

The Secret to Bakery-Style Chocolate Walnut Chip Cookies

August 5, 2026 · 34 min · Season 4 · Episode 416

About this episode

The episode features a discussion on chocolate chip cookies with a blind tasting and a recipe demonstration by guest Danielle Sepsy.

Today on Chewed Up , Michael Symon and Clinton Kelly welcome back Danielle Sepsy - the Scone Queen, bestselling cookbook author, and founder of The Hungry Gnome -for the ultimate chocolate chip cookie episode. They begin with a blind tasting of four popular store-bought cookies, comparing everything from artificial vanilla and milk chocolate to buttery flavor, crisp edges, chewiness, and dunkability before unanimously choosing their favorite. Then Danielle shares her recipe for a thick, New York bakery-style chocolate chip walnut cookie with a caramelized exterior, crisp edges, a tender center, and plenty of semisweet chocolate. She explains why cold butter, light brown sugar, chilled dough, and a hotter oven help cookies stay tall and thick; how resting the dough improves both flavor and texture; and why adding vanilla directly to the butter makes its flavor more pronounced. She also demonstrates how to balance baking soda and baking powder, avoid overmixing the flour, freeze pre-portioned dough, and bake fresh cookies whenever the craving hits. Along the way, Michael admits that he cannot stop after one cookie, Clinton revisits his infamous baking curse, and the group debates…

More episodes of Chewed UP

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Chewed UP podcast page.