About this episode

Daniel McCarthy joins Jon Harris to discuss the evolution of Republican foreign policy and the implications of Thomas Massie's defeat.

Daniel McCarthy (Heritage Foundation & Modern Age) joins Jon Harris to discuss the evolution of Republican foreign policy from Reagan to Trump, the defeat of Thomas Massie, and the tension between restraint, realism, and neoconservatism. A must-watch for conservatives wrestling with America’s role in the world today. Topics include: Reagan’s peace through strength, Bush-era nation-building, Trump’s transactional approach, historical conservative thought (Washington, Calhoun, Taft), current challenges with Iran/Israel, and why Massie’s loss reveals deeper party realities. 0:00:12 - Welcome & Introduction to Daniel McCarthy 00:01:02 - Massie Defeat & Republican Foreign Policy Vacuum Post-Reagan 00:02:17 - Pre-Reagan Conservative Foreign Policy & Cold War Mindset 00:03:32 - Ronald Reagan's "Peace Through Strength" 00:06:24 - Post-Cold War Shift: Bush Sr. to George W. Bush Neoconservatism 00:09:27 - Trump's Break with Forever Wars & America First Realism 00:10:52 - Historical Conservative Restraint: Washington, Calhoun, Taft, Rand Paul 00:17:23 - Realism vs. Idealism: Iran, Israel, Nuclear Threats & Modern Dilemmas 00:28:57 - The Limits of "Fortress America"…

People in this episode

Host: Jon Harris

Guest: Daniel McCarthy

Topics covered

• Republican foreign policy
• neoconservatism
• America's role in the world
• historical conservative thought
• Iran and Israel relations
• Thomas Massie's defeat

Keywords

• Republican foreign policy
• neoconservatism
• Thomas Massie
• Iran
• Israel
• Reagan
• Trump
• conservative thought

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Heritage Foundation, Modern Age

Places: Iran, Israel

More episodes of Conversations That Matter

• Why This Could Be the Most Important SBC Annual Meeting in Years · June 4, 2026 · 24 min
• The Zach Garris Trial Explained in 15 Minutes · June 2, 2026 · 15 min
• News Roundup: Zach Garris Censured, ARP's Kinist Report, McLean Bible Loses in Court · May 29, 2026 · 1h 22m
• Restoring Real Masculinity in the Church with Chase Davis · May 28, 2026 · 52 min
• Megan Basham - In the Valley of Cancer · May 24, 2026 · 30 min
• News Roundup: Trump's GOP, Two Roads to Compromise, and Thriving in Division · May 20, 2026 · 1h 46m

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Conversations That Matter podcast page.