About this episode

The episode explores the murder of Trish Willoughby during a family vacation and the subsequent investigation that revealed her husband's dark secrets.

In February 1991, a relaxing family vacation to Puerto Peñasco (Rocky Point), Mexico, transformed into a horrific nightmare. Trish Willoughby, a highly successful business owner from Phoenix, Arizona, was found brutally attacked inside a rental condominium at Las Conchas Beach. Her husband, Daniel Willoughby, painted the picture of an open-and-shut tragedy, claiming a random local robbery had occurred while he was visiting a nearby museum with their three young children. But back across the border, the ultimate family-man facade was already beginning to crack. Investigators quickly uncovered a twisted web of intense greed, an unraveling multi-million-dollar empire, and Dan's secret affair with his mistress, Ysenia Patino Gonzalez. What followed was an incredibly rare cross-border investigation that pushed the boundaries of international law. When Arizona investigators finally stepped into the crime scene, forensic evidence completely dismantled Dan’s alibi. Trish Willoughby, Patricia Willoughby, Daniel Hayden Willoughby, Dan Willoughby murder, Ysenia Patino Gonzalez, Rocky Point, Mexico, murder, Puerto Peñasco crime scene, Las Conchas beach condo, Arizona Supreme Court, true…

People in this episode

Host: BLACKCAT

Topics covered

• murder investigation
• family tragedy
• cross-border crime
• insurance fraud
• forensic evidence

Keywords

• Trish Willoughby
• Daniel Willoughby
• murder
• Puerto Peñasco
• cross-border investigation
• insurance fraud
• forensic evidence

Mentioned in this episode

Books & works: Crime Salad

Places: Puerto Peñasco, Las Conchas Beach, Arizona

More episodes of Crime Salad

• The Empty Casket: The Bizarre Disappearance of Julie Mott · July 19, 2026 · 38 min
• Digital Alibi: The Tragic Death of Annie Kasprzak · July 12, 2026 · 40 min
• The Real Cocaine Bear Story: Andrew Thornton Tri-State Crime Scene · June 27, 2026 · 38 min
• Introducing: The Snare from ABC News & 20/20 · June 23, 2026 · 30 min
• The Ghost Plane: The Marcus Schrenker Escape · June 19, 2026 · 40 min

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Crime Salad podcast page.