Karmelo Anthony Files for New Trial—and Wants the Judge Removed

Karmelo Anthony Files for New Trial—and Wants the Judge Removed

July 7, 2026 · 33 min

About this episode

Scott Reisch discusses Karmelo Anthony's legal team's motions for a new trial and the removal of Judge John Roach.

Karmelo Anthony's new legal team is going after the conviction—and the judge. Two new motions seek a new trial and Judge John Roach's removal from post-trial proceedings. After a 35-year sentence, the legal fight has moved from the jury room to alleged constitutional and trial errors. Scott breaks down what these motions actually mean—and whether they have a real legal path forward. Watch to the end and tell us: serious appellate issue or a post-trial legal Hail Mary? Hashtags: #KarmeloAnthony, #AustinMetcalf, #TrueCrime, #LegalAnalysis, #CourtNews, #CrimeTalk 🛍️ CRIME TALK SHOP & PARTNERS Crime Talk Store: https://crimetalknetwork.com/shop/ Run a Background Check: https://crimetalksearch.com Emergency Food Supply: https://www.rqzttm8trk.com/3Z38RPR/S5HJNJ/ Amazon Favorites: https://www.amazon.com/shop/crimetalk 🛡️ OFFICIAL DISCOUNT CODES Police Magnum — use code CRIMETALK for 10% off Invisawear Jewelry — use code CRIMETALK for 10% off Baked in Colorado — 40% off Pet CBD: https://bakedincolorado.com 🤝 JOIN THE COMMUNITY Patreon (exclusive content): https://www.patreon.com/crimetalk Official site: https://scottreisch.com X (Twitter): @CrimeTalkPod Instagram / TikTok…

Sponsors

Crime Talk Store, Invisawear Jewelry, Baked in Colorado

More episodes of Crime Talk with Scott Reisch

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Crime Talk with Scott Reisch podcast page.