S3 Ep145:  Aliza Sherman | Husband Had Motive, Lawyer Had Opportunity (Part 2)

S3 Ep145: Aliza Sherman | Husband Had Motive, Lawyer Had Opportunity (Part 2)

March 27, 2026 · 2h 15m · Season 3 · Episode 145

About this episode

The episode explores the mysterious murder of Aliza Sherman and the chilling implications of trust and betrayal in her life.

On a Sunday evening in March of 2013, 53 year old Aliza Sherman went to meet with her divorce lawyer in downtown Cleveland, just days before her long and bitter divorce was set to go to trial. She never made it inside. Instead, she was found stabbed to death on the sidewalk outside the office door. Her purse was still with her, her SUV was parked nearby, she was still wearing all of her jewelry. Nothing about it looked like a random act of violence, yet nothing about it made any sense. For years, Aliza’s murder lingered in that terrible space between mystery and suspicion, where answers feel close enough to touch, but never close enough to hold. But as time passed, the case began to expose something even more chilling than the attack itself. Little by little, the names and details surrounding two men emerged, two men Aliza should have been able to trust more than almost anyone in her life. One was tied to the home and family she had built. The other was tied to the legal fight that was supposed to help set her free. And in that realization lies the deepest horror of this case: that the people with the closest access to your life, your fears, your plans, and your vulnerabilities…

More episodes of Crime Weekly

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Crime Weekly podcast page.