About this episode

The episode explores the mysterious murder of five-year-old Willie Starchfield in 1914 London and the subsequent investigation that led to his father's arrest.

On a cold, grey January afternoon in 1914, a railway carriage travelling through north London shuttled along its route, carrying a grim secret. Beneath a third-class carriage seat lay the body of five-year-old Willie Starchfield, strangled and carefully concealed from view. Earlier that day, Willie had been sent out on an errand and never came home. The police launched a struggling investigation, hampered by a voracious press and conflicting witnesses, that eventually concluded with the arrest of Willie’s own father. Yet when the case finally reached court, the truth remained frustratingly out of reach. SOURCES The Star (1914) N.L.R. Train Murder. The Star, Fri 9 Jan 1914, p1. London, UK. Bradford Daily Argus (1914) Revenge? Bradford Daily Argus, Fri 9 Jan 1914, p1. Bradford, UK. The Star (1914) London Train Murder. The Star, Sat 10 Jan 1914, p1. London, UK. The Star (1914) N.L.R. Train Murder. The Star, Fri 9 Jan 1914, p1. London, UK. The Star (1914) Scotland Yard Dilemma. The Star, Mon 12 Jan 1914, p1. London, UK. The Star (1914) Hunt For Train Murderer. The Star, Tues 13 Jan 1914, p1. London, UK. The Star (1914) Tube “Clues” To N.L.R. Murder. The Star, Wed 14 Jan 1914, p5…

People in this episode

Host: Ben Cutmore

Topics covered

• murder mystery
• historical crime
• investigation
• family tragedy
• early 20th century

Keywords

• Willie Starchfield
• murder mystery
• 1914
• London
• investigation
• family
• crime

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: The Star, Bradford Daily Argus, Lloyd’s Weekly News

Places: London, Bradford, Londonderry

More episodes of Dark Histories

• Early America & The Savage Crimes of the Harpe Brothers · August 25, 2026 · 1h 0m
• The Grafton, The Invercauld and the The Multiple Wrecks of the Auckland Islands · August 12, 2026 · 1h 8m
• Summer Break - Charlotte Riddell: The Open Door · August 3, 2026 · 1h 17m

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Dark Histories podcast page.