The Gulf Crisis – Two Theories of American Decline

About this episode

The episode explores two theories regarding America's decline in global influence, particularly in relation to the Gulf Crisis and its implications for foreign policy.

There are roughly two camps. One argues that there is an overarching grand plan behind America's actions in Venezuela, Iran, Greenland, and against Russia's shadow fleet – a coherent strategy to choke off China's industries and make Europe energy-dependent on the United States. The other, more plausible camp sees imperial decline and the chaos that decline inevitably brings. I explore both. John Mearsheimer argues that America has suffered a catastrophic defeat. The evidence is stark: Iran has published a ten-point plan that includes the removal of American bases from the Gulf, continued uranium enrichment, and reparations – and Trump accepted it as the basis for negotiations. America is running out of Tomahawk missiles, having burned through eight to ten years of stockpiles in weeks. Its capital ships have been withdrawn out of Iranian missile range. The world's key strategic waterway is no longer under US control. But journalist Richard Medhurst makes a compelling case that this is all about China – a brutal attempt to cut off Chinese industry from Persian Gulf oil and force Beijing to negotiate from weakness. The problem is Trump. According to the New York Times, he went into…

People in this episode

Host: Nick Shepley

Topics covered

• American decline
• foreign policy
• geopolitics
• imperial decline
• China
• Middle East

Keywords

• American decline
• geopolitics
• foreign policy
• China
• Middle East
• Trump
• Iran

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: New York Times

Places: Iran, China, Venezuela, Greenland, Russia, Gulf

More episodes of Explaining History

• Militarism, Masculinity, and the Making of the American Warrior · June 10, 2026 · 43 min
• The Ottoman March on Egypt 1915 · June 3, 2026 · 30 min
• Adoption, Colonialism, and the Korean War · May 28, 2026 · 35 min
• The Shortest History of Scotland – Nation, Union, and the Rise of Nationalism · May 20, 2026 · 35 min
• Trump and Nixon in Beijing - an instructive comparison · May 19, 2026 · 31 min
• Master of Lies – Anthony Blunt, the Cambridge Spy Who Changed the Course of World War II · May 13, 2026 · 40 min