Sex and the City S1E12: "Oh Come All Ye Faithful" with Kay Poyer

Sex and the City S1E12: "Oh Come All Ye Faithful" with Kay Poyer

May 19, 2026 · 1h 20m

About this episode

Kay Poyer joins the hosts to discuss the themes of relationships and spirituality in SATC S1E12.

Kay Poyer, the potential Fran Lebowitz of 20-something trans girls, communes with us to discuss SATC S1E12 “Oh Come All Ye Faithful.” It’s a pun once again! Miranda dates a playwright who must cleanse himself with holy water after sinning (immediate shower after sex,) Charlotte is persecuted by the psychics of Manhattan, Carrie goes undercover in a big ol’ hat to try and meet Big’s mom at church, and Samantha exorcises her biggest demon: the man she loves has a small penis. We share holy wisdom on how churches are the new bars for gen-z men, cigs are classic while vapes are sexless, how Charlotte and Amelia have shared clairvoyant trauma, and that truth, communication, and sisterhood are the only uppers our ladies need in a bathroom stall when talking tiny dicks. Monarch is the personal finance app that tracks everything—accounts, investments, savings goals, and spending. Get your first year of Monarch Core for half off—just $50—with promo code GIRLSREWATCH. Stop the guesswork and start something that works. Join Weight Watchers Core+ program for the ultimate weight loss support and better results at weightwatchers.com/GIRLSREWATCH ! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit…

People in this episode

Hosts: Amelia, Evan Lazarus, Amelia Ritthaler

Guest: Kay Poyer

Topics covered

Sponsors

Monarch, Weight Watchers

More episodes of Girls Rewatch: Sex and the City

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Girls Rewatch: Sex and the City podcast page.