Supernatural Music Extravaganza: Series Finale - Carry On My Wayward Song (Rights)

Supernatural Music Extravaganza: Series Finale - Carry On My Wayward Song (Rights)

From In Defense of Fandom by Sadie Witkowski

January 6, 2026 · 36 min

About this episode

The episode explores the complexities of music licensing in Supernatural, highlighting the impact of capitalism on the show's soundtrack.

Welcome to the series finale of Supernatural Music Extravaganza! In this episode, the Denim Wrapped Nightmares and In Defense of Fandom crews tackle the eternal question: "Why does my Supernatural sound different on {insert name of streaming platform}?!" Spoiler alert: blame capitalism! The hosts explain the wild world of music licensing, from the show's early "oops, we only bought DVD rights" days to the later "give us your songs FOREVER" era. Turns out those iconic needle drops cost serious upfront cash, which is why Season 1 Dean might be rocking out to "Generic Rock Song #4" instead of AC/DC. RIP original soundtrack, we hardly knew ye (unless you own the DVD). Featuring insights from Jensen Ackles on budget woes, a deep dive into why physical media matters, and heartfelt tributes to favorite Supernatural needle drops—from "Heat of the Moment" torture to Bob Seger brotherhood feels. Plus: important intel on where to snag those Radio Company vinyls before they're gone again. The moral of the story? Buy the Blu-rays. Buy the CDs. Stream responsibly. Go to the shows. And never trust a tinkerbell. Click here to learn more about music supervision and Alexandra Patsavas. Catchup on…

People in this episode

Hosts: Sadie Witkowski, Denim Wrapped Nightmares, In Defense of Fandom

Topics covered

  • music licensing
  • Supernatural
  • soundtrack
  • capitalism
  • physical media
  • music supervision

Keywords

  • Supernatural
  • music licensing
  • soundtrack
  • Jensen Ackles
  • physical media
  • music supervision
  • capitalism
  • needle drops

Mentioned in this episode

Books & works: Supernatural, Heat of the Moment, Generic Rock Song #4, Carry On My Wayward Song

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the In Defense of Fandom podcast page.