The Accidental Landlord Playbook: When to Hire a Property Manager

The Accidental Landlord Playbook: When to Hire a Property Manager

March 10, 2026 · 34 min · Episode 82

About this episode

This episode discusses the decision-making process for accidental landlords on whether to manage their rental property themselves or hire a property manager.

Renting out your personal home can turn you into a landlord overnight. But once the lease is signed, the big question quickly follows: should you manage the property yourself, or hire a property manager? In Part 3 of The Accidental Landlord Playbook, we break down the real decision accidental landlords face when turning their former home into a rental. Managing a property yourself can save money—but it also means handling leasing, maintenance calls, late rent, legal compliance, and everything in between. In this episode, we walk through the factors that should guide your decision, including the time commitment, risks, and when professional property management actually makes sense. If you’re renting out your personal residence for the first time, this conversation will help you decide which path is right for you. Subscribe for more practical insights on real estate investing, accidental landlording, and property management in Indianapolis and Central Indiana.

More episodes of Indy REI with T&H Realty

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Indy REI with T&H Realty podcast page.