QB Truth Serum: Ranking All 32 Starters

QB Truth Serum: Ranking All 32 Starters

From Inside The Eagles RedZone by Erik Williams

May 20, 2026 · 1h 44m

About this episode

Erik and Matt rank all 32 starting quarterbacks in the NFL while discussing the significance of 'prove it years' for quarterbacks.

On today’s episode, Erik and Matt kick things off by diving into the idea of “prove it years” for quarterbacks — and why, in reality, every season is a prove-it season in today’s NFL. With massive QB contracts constantly reshaping rosters and salary cap decisions, the guys break down how organizations evaluate whether a quarterback is truly worth building around, or if resources are better spent elsewhere. Then it’s time for the main event. Erik and Matt rank all 32 starting quarterbacks in the NFL from top to bottom. From the elite franchise changers, to the polarizing middle tier, to the quarterbacks teams may already be looking to replace, no one is safe. The debates get heated, the disagreements get loud, and plenty of fanbases are probably going to be furious with where their guy landed. Who’s overrated? Who deserves more respect? And which quarterbacks are being set up to fail? The full QB rankings episode is here. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/inside-the-eagles-redzone--3314384/support .

People in this episode

Host: Erik Williams

Guest: Matt

Topics covered

  • quarterback rankings
  • NFL
  • prove it years
  • salary cap
  • team evaluation

Keywords

  • quarterbacks
  • NFL rankings
  • salary cap
  • team evaluation
  • football

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: NFL

More episodes of Inside The Eagles RedZone

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Inside The Eagles RedZone podcast page.