Church Hurt: How to Spot Toxic Churches & Create A Healthy Culture Instead | w/ Top Theologian Scot McKnight (288)

Church Hurt: How to Spot Toxic Churches & Create A Healthy Culture Instead | w/ Top Theologian Scot McKnight (288)

March 17, 2026 · 40 min · Season 8 · Episode 288

About this episode

In this episode, Jenilee Samuel and Scot McKnight discuss how to identify toxic church environments and foster a healthy church culture.

...and how to heal from them! Their brokenness doesn't have to become yours, but first you must be able to identify if that's where your church hurt and confusion is coming from. If you’ve ever experienced church hurt, felt confused by leadership, or wondered why something felt “off” but you couldn’t explain it—this conversation will likely put words to what you’ve been sensing. In this episode, I sit down with world-renown theologian and author Scot McKnight to talk about toxic church culture, narcissistic leadership, and what it actually looks like to build a healthy, Christ-centered church rooted in goodness. We break down why toxic churches often look healthy on the outside, how power gets misused behind the scenes, and how to recognize the difference between spiritual authority and control. If you’ve been hurt by church, this episode will help you understand what happened—and begin to move forward with peace, comfort and direction. Hit play now, and share with the friend who's been looking for this! ⏱️ TIMESTAMPS 0:00 The truth about church hurt 1:10 Why toxic churches look healthy on the outside 4:30 What “Tov” culture actually means 8:45 How power gets abused in church…

People in this episode

Host: Jenilee Samuel

Guest: Scot McKnight

Topics covered

Keywords

More episodes of Java with Jen: Hearing God’s Voice in Everyday Life | Prophecy, Faith Teaching, Hearing Jesus

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Java with Jen: Hearing God’s Voice in Everyday Life | Prophecy, Faith Teaching, Hearing Jesus podcast page.