What Should Jurors Do When Something Feels Wrong in Court?

What Should Jurors Do When Something Feels Wrong in Court?

From Lawyer Talk: Off the Record by Stephen E. Palmer - Attorney At Law

May 26, 2026 · 6 min · Season 9 · Episode 551

About this episode

The episode discusses what jurors should do if they suspect misconduct in court, using the Murdaugh trial as a case study.

Examining Rebecca Hill’s Role in the Murdaugh Jury Controversy We’re picking up the conversation about the Alex Murdaugh trial—specifically, a really interesting question from one of our listeners about jury misconduct. What happens if you’re a juror and you notice something shady, but the person you’re supposed to report it to is the one causing the problem? Steve chats through the real-life dilemma of blowing the whistle, who you’re supposed to trust in the courtroom, and how things are supposed to go down when there’s a problem on the jury. Whether you’re a courtroom drama fan or just curious about how these big cases work behind the scenes, you’ll definitely want to stick around for this episode! What should a juror do if they suspect jury misconduct, like in the Murdaugh case? If a juror suspects misconduct similar to the Murdaugh case, they should try to alert the judge directly, even publicly if necessary, as the person they would normally report to may be implicated. Speaker A explains that it’s possible to ask to speak privately with the judge or submit a note if other channels are compromised. How are concerns about jury tampering typically reported during a trial…

People in this episode

Hosts: Steve, Stephen E. Palmer

Topics covered

  • jury misconduct
  • courtroom ethics
  • Murdaugh trial
  • juror responsibilities
  • legal dilemmas

Keywords

  • juror misconduct
  • Murdaugh case
  • courtroom drama
  • jury tampering
  • legal advice

More episodes of Lawyer Talk: Off the Record

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Lawyer Talk: Off the Record podcast page.