Inside the Karmelo Anthony Trial, with Court TV Reporter Cody Thomas

About this episode

The episode discusses the guilty verdict in Karmelo Anthony's murder trial and features insights from Court TV reporter Cody Thomas.

The MK True Crime Show hosts Ashleigh Merchant and Dave Aronberg join the program to discuss the guilty verdict in Karmelo Anthony’s murder trial this week, if the jury’s 35 year sentence was appropriate, explaining what a Batson challenge is and its relevance to the Karmelo trial, why Anthony did not testify on his own behalf, why a prior altercation at school may have been key to keeping him off the stand, the dramatic start to prominent Florida real estate broker George Pino’s trial for vessel homicide and manslaughter, why the case went from three misdemeanor charges to two felony charges, the circumstances surrounding the fatal 2022 boat crash that led to Pino’s prosecution, and later Ashleigh and Dave are joined by Court TV field reporter Cody Thomas to discuss his experience in the courtroom during the Karmelo Anthony trial, what he observed that the public was barred from seeing, the defense and prosecution’s relationships with their witnesses, the security measures put in place for the emotionally-charged trial, the tensions among the crowds outside the courthouse, the diversity inside the courtroom the public did not see, and more. Ashleigh Merchant…

People in this episode

Hosts: Ashleigh Merchant, Dave Aronberg

Guest: Cody Thomas

Topics covered

• Karmelo Anthony trial
• courtroom experience
• jury verdict
• vessel homicide
• legal challenges
• real estate broker
• boat crash

Keywords

• Karmelo Anthony
• murder trial
• guilty verdict
• Court TV
• Cody Thomas
• vessel homicide
• George Pino
• Batson challenge
• boat crash
• Florida

Sponsors

SelectQuote, Shopify

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Court TV, MK Media

More episodes of MK True Crime

• Karmelo Anthony’s Fate, Nick Reiner Seeks Trust Fund for Defense, and Defending Clients Like Weinstein and Diddy, with Teny Geragos · June 12, 2026 · 35 min
• Karmelo Anthony Found GUILTY, Michael Jackson’s Verdict, and Revisiting the Scott Peterson Case · June 10, 2026 · 59 min
• Karmelo Anthony Refuses to Testify, Karen Read Sues Police, Aaron Spencer’s Murder Charge Dismissed, with Chris Stewart · June 9, 2026 · 55 min
• In The Well LIVE from CrimeCon, with Detective Moses Castillo · June 5, 2026 · 34 min
• Judge DENIES Motion in Tyler Robinson Hearing, Karmelo Anthony’s Defense, and Serial Killer Artifacts at Zak Bagans’ Haunted Museum · June 4, 2026 · 56 min
• Positively Legal LIVE from CrimeCon, with Vinnie Politan, Joseph Scott Morgan, and Greg Schiller · June 3, 2026 · 39 min