Ep:102 | Herb Baumeister | The Serial Killer You've Never Heard About | 10,000 Bones in Backyard | Murder Unscripted

Ep:102 | Herb Baumeister | The Serial Killer You've Never Heard About | 10,000 Bones in Backyard | Murder Unscripted

From Murder Unscripted by Murder Unscripted Pod

May 5, 2026 · 1h 7m · Season 3 · Episode 18

About this episode

The episode explores the disturbing case of Herb Baumeister, a serial killer whose crimes went unnoticed by his family for years.

His 13-year-old son found a skull in the backyard. Herb Baumeister said it was from his father's medical collection. His wife believed him. Over ten thousand human bone fragments were eventually recovered from Fox Hollow Farm — the 18-acre Indiana estate where Herb hosted family pool parties, ran a thrift store empire, and murdered at least eleven men, possibly twenty-five, while his wife and kids had no idea. Melissa walks through one of the most disturbing cases in our "Who the Bleep Did I Marry?" block cases MU has ever covered — including the I-70 Strangler theory, the missing tapes, and the DNA work that is still identifying victims in 2026.

People in this episode

Host: Melissa

Topics covered

  • true crime
  • serial killers
  • unsolved cases
  • forensic science
  • family dynamics
  • missing persons

Keywords

  • Herb Baumeister
  • serial killer
  • Fox Hollow Farm
  • human bones
  • true crime
  • I-70 Strangler
  • DNA identification
  • missing tapes

Mentioned in this episode

Places: Fox Hollow Farm, Indiana

More episodes of Murder Unscripted

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Murder Unscripted podcast page.