What Was the Americanist Heresy? (Did it Really Exist?)

What Was the Americanist Heresy? (Did it Really Exist?)

July 1, 2026

About this episode

The episode discusses the concept of Americanism as a heresy and its implications for Catholic identity in America.

America is a special place. And, it even has it's own heresy. In this podcast, Reuben Slife and Marc Barnes discuss Leo XIII's condemnation of "Americanism," and the controversy that it caused. Some US bishops replied to the Pope that no one actually adhered to Americanism, and that it was effectively a "phantom heresy." But, is there something particular to the American way of being Catholic that needs correction? How does this teaching on Americanism relate to America today, on the 250th anniversary?

More episodes of New Polity

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the New Polity podcast page.