Has Tipping Gone Too Far? A Business Owner's Perspective

Has Tipping Gone Too Far? A Business Owner's Perspective

March 4, 2026 · 18 min

About this episode

The episode discusses the complexities of tipping culture from both restaurant owners' and customers' perspectives.

Most restaurant owners think about tips from the payroll side. But your customers are thinking about tips from the experience side, and right now, that experience is broken. In this episode, Matt and Mike talk about tipping culture from both sides of the table. As customers frustrated by guilt tipping, receipt clutter, and being asked for 25% on an empty cup. And as accountants who keep finding restaurant clients eligible for the FICA tip credit that no one ever told them about. They compare the U.S. tipping model to what they've experienced overseas, talk through why transparency and simplicity are a competitive advantage, and challenge the "that's how everyone does it" mindset that keeps most operators stuck. We get into: Why the checkout experience at most restaurants is working against you The difference between earning a tip and guilting someone into one The FICA tip credit and why most eligible restaurants have never claimed it What "no tax on tips" actually changes for employers vs. employees Why simplifying your tip structure is a customer experience decision, not just a payroll one If you run a restaurant and haven't rethought your tip policy in a…

Topics covered

More episodes of One Step Better Podcast

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the One Step Better Podcast podcast page.