098: Hillbilly Eulogy feat. Amanda Marcotte

From Posting Through It by Jared Holt and Michael Edison Hayden

April 20, 2026 · 1h 9m · Season 2 · Episode 98

About this episode

The episode discusses JD Vance's political viability and critiques his alignment with the MAGA movement, featuring guest Amanda Marcotte.

How many y’all like JD Vance? That’s the question some proponents of MAGA are asking as the movement grapples with the inevitable reality of Trumpism ending. Either Trump’s term will run out, or the McDonald's will take its course, or an angry mob will secure control of the White House — something has to give here. Superficially, Vance seems like the obvious choice to replace Trump... but maybe he just isn’t up to the job. That’s the take of our guest this week, Amanda Marcotte , a senior writer at Salon who has extensively chronicled the missteps of Peter Thiel’s humanoid political project and current Vice President. Jared, Mike and Amanda run through some of Vance’s low lights in this episode and determine that he doesn’t really have a constituency to fall back on. Not even fascists find him particularly compelling. So hide your “woke pussy” and look out for falling “MAGA cock.” This episode is a "hillbilly elegy" of another kind. Links for Amanda: Check out "Standing Room Only" ( Salon Newsletter / YouTube ) Follow her on Bluesky Committee to Protect Journalists Petition: RELEASE JOURNALIST AHMED SHIHAB-ELDIN FROM DETENTION Transition Music: "One Night…

People in this episode

Hosts: Jared Holt, Michael Edison Hayden

Guest: Amanda Marcotte

Topics covered

JD Vance
Trumpism
MAGA movement
political analysis
Amanda Marcotte
Salon
political commentary

Keywords

JD Vance
Trumpism
MAGA
Amanda Marcotte
politics
Salon
political commentary

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Salon, Committee to Protect Journalists