133: She Made Them Do It: Sarah Jo Pender

About this episode

The episode explores the controversial case of Sarah Jo Pender, who was convicted of a double murder she claims she did not commit.

Was Sarah Jo Pender a master manipulator who orchestrated a brutal double murder, or was she a young woman caught in a flawed investigation and wrongfully convicted? One of the most controversial true-crime cases of the 2000s. Sarah Jo Pender was convicted in 2002 for the murders of Andrew Cataldi and Tricia Nordman, a crime prosecutors argued she planned and directed. Dubbed the "female Charles Manson", Pender maintained her innocence throughout her trial and imprisonment. The Lifetime movie She Made Them Do It , starring Jenna Dewan depicted Sarah's story. Sources: https://www.hulu.com/series/5eb21b90-555a-4dc3-9b6c-60c8f7087bd4 She Made Them Do It https://law.justia.com/cases/indiana/court-of-appeals/2003/12090302-smb.html https://www.aetv.com/articles/sarah-pender-escaped-prison-many-call-wrongful-conviction

Topics covered

• true crime
• wrongful conviction
• murder case
• manipulation
• investigation flaws

Keywords

• Sarah Jo Pender
• double murder
• wrongful conviction
• manipulation
• true crime

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Lifetime, A&E

Books & works: She Made Them Do It

More episodes of Residue: A True Crime Podcast

• 134: David (1988): A Survival Story · June 9, 2026 · 39 min
• 132: Cruel Doubt: The Murder of Leith Von Stein · May 26, 2026 · 35 min
• 131: Song Sung Blue: The Mike and Claire Sardina Story · May 19, 2026 · 35 min
• 130: Abducted: The Carlina White Story · May 12, 2026 · 35 min
• 129: I Know My First Name Is Steven: PART 2, Cary Stayner the Yosemite Park Killer · May 5, 2026 · 45 min
• 128: I Know My First Name Is Steven: Part 1, Steven Stayner · April 28, 2026 · 1h 3m