The Fear at Hotel San Carlos Felt Different - Ghost Hunting in Downtown Phoenix, Arizona

About this episode

Tony and Shy investigate the haunted Hotel San Carlos, sharing unsettling experiences and answering listener questions.

Is Hotel San Carlos really haunted? This week on Scaredycast, Tony and Shy spend the night investigating one of Arizona's most infamous haunted locations: the historic Hotel San Carlos in downtown Phoenix. What started as a paranormal investigation quickly turned into one of the most unsettling experiences we've ever had. Tony describes feeling an overwhelming sense of fear and dread unlike anything he's experienced at any other supposedly haunted location. Was it paranormal, psychological, or something else entirely? We also answer listener questions, including: 👻 Which horror villain probably has the worst search history? 🎬 Which celebrity would make the worst paranormal investigator? 🚪 If you found a portal to another dimension in your closet, would you go through it? Subscribe for weekly horror, paranormal, cryptid, conspiracy, and creepy content. Check out our YouTube , where you can now WATCH episodes of Scaredycast! And follow us on social! Become a PATRON to support the show and get spooky exclusive content! Original music by Mangy Bones Visit Scaredycast.com for updates on the show, live show event dates, merch, and more! Scaredycast is sponsored by: ValuSesh ! Want…

People in this episode

Hosts: Tony, Shy

Topics covered

• ghost hunting
• haunted locations
• paranormal investigation
• listener questions
• psychological fear

Keywords

• haunted hotel
• paranormal
• ghosts
• psychological fear
• listener questions

Sponsors

ValuSesh

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Scaredycast, Cryin' Coyote BBQ

Places: Hotel San Carlos, Phoenix

More episodes of Scaredycast

• The Crash, Backrooms & The Most Haunted Fast Food Restaurant · June 1, 2026 · 1h 6m
• Goblins, Bees & Bathroom Floods · May 24, 2026 · 42 min
• Which Slasher Mask Would You Wear FOREVER? · May 18, 2026 · 44 min
• Haunted Luxor Hotel, Bee Swarm Crime & Loveland Frogman Gets Official · May 10, 2026 · 56 min
• Childhood Paranormal Encounters & Dynamite Revenge · May 3, 2026 · 50 min
• “The Bible Study Kidnapper” Case is INSANE! + Horror Questions & Movie Reviews · April 26, 2026 · 33 min