About this episode

Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan create a nostalgic mixtape of guilty pleasure songs while debating their choices.

Welcome back to I Killed My Tamagotchi! Tommy James and Alex "A-Town" Ryan kick off the first-ever Secret Mixtape, each bringing ten guilty pleasure songs to the table but with only ten spots available, every pick has to earn its place. Along the way, they debate what truly qualifies as a guilty pleasure, defend some questionable favorites, and try to build the ultimate nostalgic playlist. Plus, "Where Were We When?" rewinds to June 28, 1997, another Heartthrob email delivers a brand-new clue, and the nostalgia keeps rolling. Press play... because every mixtape tells a story.

People in this episode

Hosts: Tommy James, Alex "A-Town" Ryan

Topics covered

• guilty pleasure songs
• nostalgia
• music debate
• mixtape
• playlist building

Keywords

• guilty pleasure
• nostalgic playlist
• music debate
• mixtape
• Liquid Dreams

Mentioned in this episode

Books & works: Liquid Dreams

More episodes of Second Rounds On Us

• Tape #006: You Only Get 10: Guilty Pleasure Movies - I Watched Spice World Every Sunday - I Killed My Tamagotchi · July 11, 2026 · 1h 53m
• Tape #005: Secret Mixtape Vol. 1: Deluxe Edition – I Had Britney Spears Posters on My Ceiling - I Killed My Tamagotchi · July 5, 2026 · 1h 11m
• Tape #003: MMPR Part 1 – They Should’ve Killed the Green Ranger - I Killed My Tamagotchi · June 20, 2026 · 1h 23m
• Tape #002: Nickelodeon Game Shows – I Didn't Have Cable - I Killed My Tamagotchi · June 12, 2026 · 1h 30m
• Tape #001: Disney Renaissance Songs – I’ve Never Seen Tarzan - I Killed My Tamagotchi · June 5, 2026 · 1h 23m

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Second Rounds On Us podcast page.