#265 A SLAM DUNK Debate For Catholics (Fatima DEBATE REVIEW)

About this episode

Joe reviews a debate on the authenticity of the Fatima apparitions between Ethan Muse and Sean Luke.

Joe reviews the recent debate on Capturing Catholicism between Ethan Muse and Sean of Anglican Aesthetics over the apparitions at Fatima. Transcript: Joe: Welcome back to Shameless Popery. I’m Joe Heschmeyer, and you all voted overwhelmingly for me to do a debate review of Sean Luke versus Ethan Muse on the question of whether the alleged Mary and Apparitions and Fatima were really Mary or whether, as Sean Luke claims, was really a demon. Now, this is not going to be a full blow by blow of their whole three hour debate. I’m going to actually sit down with Ethan for a fuller convers...

People in this episode

Host: Joe Heschmeyer

Guest: Ethan Muse

Topics covered

• debate review
• Catholicism
• Fatima apparitions
• religious debate
• Christianity
• spirituality

Keywords

• Fatima
• Catholicism
• debate
• Ethan Muse
• Sean Luke
• Mary apparitions
• religion

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Capturing Catholicism

Places: Fatima

More episodes of Shameless Popery

• #271 The False Gospel Many Catholics Secretly Believe · June 9, 2026
• #270 Does “Magnifica Humanitas” Contradict Catholic Teaching? (Just War) · June 2, 2026
• #269 Responding (Lovingly) to Wes Huff’s Reasons For Not Being Catholic · May 26, 2026
• #268 The Jewish Roots of “Christ Is King” · May 19, 2026
• #267 “Bible In Context” Got This Wrong In His Response to Me · May 12, 2026
• #266 This Brand New Sola Scriptura Argument Surprised Me… · May 5, 2026