#267 “Bible In Context” Got This Wrong In His Response to Me

About this episode

Joe Heschmeyer responds to criticisms from the Instagram account Bible in Context regarding Catholic teachings.

Bible in Context is an Instagram page that regularly replies to Catholic creators, and has replied to several clips of Joe. Today Joe responds back! Transcript: Joe: Welcome back to Shameless Popery. I’m Joe Heschmeyer. Many of you may be familiar with the Instagram account Bible in context. It’s run by a guy by the name of Patrick O’Brien, and he’s built a large following attacking Catholic teaching. He’s called the Rosary Demonic, said praying to saints is communicating with demons, and even called the Eucharist blasphemy. So needless to say, no fan of Catholici...

People in this episode

Host: Joe Heschmeyer

Topics covered

• Catholic teaching
• Instagram responses
• religious debate
• Eucharist
• Rosary

Keywords

• Bible in Context
• Catholicism
• Joe Heschmeyer
• Patrick O’Brien
• Eucharist
• Rosary
• religious debate

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Bible in Context

More episodes of Shameless Popery

• #271 The False Gospel Many Catholics Secretly Believe · June 9, 2026
• #270 Does “Magnifica Humanitas” Contradict Catholic Teaching? (Just War) · June 2, 2026
• #269 Responding (Lovingly) to Wes Huff’s Reasons For Not Being Catholic · May 26, 2026
• #268 The Jewish Roots of “Christ Is King” · May 19, 2026
• #266 This Brand New Sola Scriptura Argument Surprised Me… · May 5, 2026
• #265 A SLAM DUNK Debate For Catholics (Fatima DEBATE REVIEW) · April 22, 2026