Will Murdaugh's Judge Grant This Extraordinary Demand?
About this episode
The episode discusses a rare legal demand by Alex Murdaugh's defense for a comprehensive search of case-related files and records.
Alex Murdaugh's defense wants a South Carolina judge to order something rare: a full search of every file, agency, and personnel record connected to his case, across ten categories, with prosecutors swearing in writing that nothing favorable to Murdaugh remains hidden. Judge Debra McCaslin hears arguments on that motion August 14, 2026. Tony Brueski breaks down what's actually being asked for, and why. The motion leans on the record of lead investigator David Owen, who led the Murdaugh case and, years earlier, a separate 2015 murder investigation a judge later quashed after ruling the state withheld favorable evidence for nearly a decade, including a mother's account Owen denied under oath. It also notes agent Ryan Kelly, who told Murdaugh's jury nothing tied alternate suspect Eddie Smith to the murders before being fired from an unrelated Charleston County job in June 2026. Retired FBI Special Agent Jennifer Coffindaffer joins to weigh whether the demand is a fishing expedition or something this investigation has genuinely earned, and covers the fight over the white shirt Murdaugh wore the night Maggie and Paul were killed, tested negative for human blood, then rendered…
More episodes of The Re-Trial Of Alex Murdaugh
- Murdaugh Claims SLED Agent Did WHAT?!
- What Creighton Waters Learned About the Murdaugh Evidence in Open Court
- What SLED Never Told Creighton Waters About the Murdaugh Weapons
- Murdaugh: Why Are Prosecutors Fighting His DNA Request?
- What Alex Murdaugh's Defense Says It Never Received
- What Alex Murdaugh Said In 2023 Is Now The State's Weapon
Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the The Re-Trial Of Alex Murdaugh podcast page.