About this episode

This episode recaps the oral arguments in Charlie Adelson's appeal regarding his murder conviction and the judges' responses.

The oral arguments in Charlie Adelson's appeal took place today before Florida's First District Court of Appeal in Tallahassee. For 40 minutes, three judges — Lori S. Rowe, Thomas D. Winokur, and M. Kemmerly Thomas — heard competing arguments about whether Adelson's 2023 murder conviction should stand. Defense attorney Michael Ufferman argued that pretrial publicity made a fair trial in Leon County impossible. He pointed to devastating jury selection numbers: 130 prospective jurors were questioned, 54 had formed opinions, and 53 believed Adelson was guilty before opening statements. Jurors were overheard discussing the case after being told not to. Ufferman called it the clearest case for a change of venue imaginable. The state saw it differently. Assistant Attorney General Robert Charles Lee reminded the court that Adelson accepted the jury on the record, never filed a written venue motion, and failed to renew his objection. His argument was direct: media coverage is everywhere now, Tallahassee isn't uniquely biased, and the evidence would have convicted Adelson in any courtroom in Florida. The judges challenged both sides but gave no indication of how they'll rule or when…

Topics covered

• legal proceedings
• murder conviction
• appeal hearing
• jury selection
• media coverage
• court arguments

Keywords

• Charlie Adelson
• murder conviction
• appeal hearing
• jury selection
• pretrial publicity
• Florida court
• Donna Adelson

Mentioned in this episode

Places: Florida, Leon County, Tallahassee, South Dakota

More episodes of The Trial Of Donna Adelson | The Murder Of Dan Markel

• Adelson Case Week In Review: Charlie's Appeal Arguments, Donna's Prison Transfer, and the Wendi Question · January 11, 2026 · 43 min
• Charlie Adelson Appeal: February 2026 Oral Arguments — Everything You Need to Know · January 6, 2026 · 17 min
• Donna Adelson: Cracks, Clues, and the Moment She Slipped | 2025 True Crime · January 3, 2026 · 1h 5m
• Wendi Freezes, Robert Speaks: The Adelson Kids Break Silence | 2025 True Crime · January 2, 2026 · 35 min
• Inside the 9 Moments That Destroyed Donna’s Defense | 2025 True Crime · January 1, 2026 · 1h 24m
• Jeffrey LaCasse Testifies: Wendi Adelson’s Secrets Hit the Courtroom | 2025 True Crime · December 31, 2025 · 26 min

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the The Trial Of Donna Adelson | The Murder Of Dan Markel podcast page.