212: The Other Man

212: The Other Man

From This American Life by This American Life

April 5, 2026 · 1h 3m · Episode 212

About this episode

The episode explores how the introduction of new individuals can alter existing relationships and dynamics within families and communities.

What happens when a new guy comes on the scene and changes the way everyone relates to each other? Visit thisamericanlife.org/lifepartners to sign up for our premium subscription. Prologue: Ira talks with Sarah Koenig about the first and only time a movie star came to her family's house when she was a kid. It didn't go well, for the celebrity or for her. The star was Robert Redford. He arrived and immediately stole all the attention her parents usually lavished on her, their youngest. Worse, they were nervous and strange around him, not themselves at all. Young Sarah was not pleased. Robert Redford paid the price. (6 minutes) Act One: Davy Rothbart's mother is funny, rational, and by most measures, pretty normal. Except that she spends every day in the company of an ancient Buddhist monk named Aaron, who no one else can see. Davy talks to his brothers, father, and eventually his mom, and asks the question they've somehow never managed to discuss: do any of them actually believe he's real? (26 minutes) Act Two: Congressman Jesse Jackson, Jr. had always lived in the shadow of his father's name. But just before his primary, an aide delivered strange news: a second Jesse Jackson had…

People in this episode

Host: Ira

Guest: Sarah Koenig

Topics covered

  • relationships
  • family dynamics
  • politics
  • celebrity
  • perception
  • identity

Keywords

  • Robert Redford
  • Davy Rothbart
  • Jesse Jackson
  • Buddhist monk
  • family
  • politics
  • celebrity encounter

More episodes of This American Life

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the This American Life podcast page.