249 - The Disappearance of John & Shelly Markley

249 - The Disappearance of John & Shelly Markley

From Trace Evidence by Steven Pacheco

June 25, 2025 · 1h 43m

About this episode

The episode explores the mysterious disappearance of John and Shelly Markley in 1995 and the ongoing investigation into their case.

As Christmas of 1995 drew near, many families in rural Ohio drew closer and felt themselves caught up in the joy and pageantry of the holiday season. Unfortunately, for one family, the holiday would forever be associated with pain and grief, loss and doubt, a disappearance and the unknown. John and Shelly Markley were devoted and loving parents to their five children. During a week already marked by a family tragedy, John and Shelly mysteriously vanished on the morning of Friday, December 15th. The last sighting of the couple was made by a bank teller who waited on them at the drive up window. In addition to John and Shelly, the woman saw a third individual, a man who has never been identified. Investigators found themselves caught up in a case with just one witness, almost no physical evidence and few in any clues. As the case unfolded, detectives would learn a lot about John and Shelly and everyone else in their lives. Within weeks an unknown caller began ringing the family home, demanding cash in exchange for the return of the missing couple and that would take the investigation in a completely different direction. Nearly thirty years later, what became of John and Shelly…

People in this episode

Host: Steven Pacheco

Topics covered

  • disappearance
  • true crime
  • mystery
  • investigation
  • family tragedy

Keywords

  • disappearance
  • John Markley
  • Shelly Markley
  • Ohio
  • true crime
  • investigation
  • mystery
  • family tragedy

Sponsors

CrimeCon

Mentioned in this episode

Places: Ohio

More episodes of Trace Evidence

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Trace Evidence podcast page.