Kohberger: What The Internet Got Wrong First

Kohberger: What The Internet Got Wrong First

July 19, 2026 · 37 min

About this episode

Tony Brueski discusses conspiracy theories surrounding the University of Idaho murders and the implications of DNA evidence in the case against Bryan Kohberger.

Two conspiracy theories have trailed the University of Idaho murders since before Bryan Kohberger was ever arrested, and Tony Brueski tackles both in this combined look at the case for True Crime Today. The first theory ruined an innocent man's life before Kohberger was ever named a suspect in this case. The internet decided a grieving young man who'd just lost the woman he loved was responsible, largely because he called her phone repeatedly that morning, something with a completely innocent explanation once you know the full timeline. We break down why the roommates waiting hours to call 911 isn't the smoking gun people think, what their private writings do and don't show, the theory that they were spared for being involved, and why a judge called the internet's alternate suspects rank speculation. The second theory says Kohberger's DNA was planted on the knife sheath left behind at the scene. The lab that tested it says the amount recovered wasn't a faint trace, it was hundreds of times more genetic material than investigators typically find in a case like this one. We go through the unidentified blood inside the house, the mismatched DNA under a victim's fingernails, the hair…

More episodes of True Crime Today | Daily True Crime News & Interviews

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the True Crime Today | Daily True Crime News & Interviews podcast page.