Murdaugh's Lawyer Has History With The Judge Deciding His Fate

About this episode

This episode discusses the implications of Judge Debra McCaslin's history with defense counsel Dick Harpootlian in the Alex Murdaugh case.

The latest Alex Murdaugh case update concerns the bench, not the defendant. The South Carolina Supreme Court has vested Judge Debra McCaslin with exclusive jurisdiction over all proceedings in the Murdaugh matter — including any retrial on charges that he murdered his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul — and her professional history with lead defense counsel Dick Harpootlian is now a matter of public scrutiny. The record, as reported: early in her career, McCaslin rented office space from Harpootlian, and during her judicial screening she identified him among the attorneys who shaped her legal career, reportedly stating he made an impression on her life. In this episode, defense attorney and former felony prosecutor Eric Faddis applies the actual legal standards to those facts — what judicial disqualification requires, how appearance-of-impropriety analysis works, who can raise the issue, and why prior professional association between bench and bar is far more common, and far less determinative, than headlines suggest. Faddis then turns to the substantive authority McCaslin now holds. The Supreme Court's reversal — rooted in former clerk of court Becky Hill's misconduct, to which she…

People in this episode

Guest: Eric Faddis

Topics covered

• legal standards
• judicial disqualification
• Murdaugh case
• evidentiary disputes
• professional associations

Keywords

• Murdaugh case
• Judge Debra McCaslin
• Dick Harpootlian
• Eric Faddis
• judicial disqualification
• evidentiary disputes
• South Carolina Supreme Court

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: South Carolina Supreme Court, Real Story Media, Becky Hill

More episodes of True Crime Today | Daily True Crime News & Interviews

• Why Does Nick Reiner’s Petition Say He ‘Loved His Parents’? · June 12, 2026 · 24 min
• Did BTK Killer Dennis Rader Ask If The Disk Was Traceable Before Mailing It? · June 12, 2026 · 22 min
• Can Nick Reiner Inherit From The Parents He's Accused Of Killing? · June 12, 2026 · 18 min
• Nick Reiner Asked A Judge For $1.5 Million — And Soap · June 12, 2026 · 16 min
• Why Did a Kidnapping 7 Miles Away Become the Biggest Story in the Nancy Guthrie Case? · June 12, 2026 · 17 min
• Twenty Years of Jesse Ridgway Faking Crises and It’s Only Getting Worse · June 11, 2026 · 49 min