2. The Fishermen Who Took Down a Giant

About this episode

This episode explores the story of fishermen challenging federal regulations and the implications of the Chevron doctrine.

Wayne Reichle – who’s been in the fishing business his whole life – had never heard of the Chevron doctrine. That's the two-step legal test that courts used for the past 40 years to decide whether a federal agency had the authority to make a regulation. "No idea," said Reichle, president of New Jersey-based Lund's Fisheries. "Myself, and many, many fellow fishermen had no idea what the Chevron doctrine was." That changed after a group of fishermen challenged a federal regulation requiring the herring industry to pay for onboard federal observers. "I think there’s quite a few that know what the Chevron doctrine is today," Reichle said. This season on UnCommon Law, we’re exploring the limits of agency power. To what extent are federal agencies authorized to create and implement regulations that aren't explicitly mandated by Congress? And what happens when an agency goes too far? In this episode, the story of the fishermen who fought back. Featuring: Wayne Reichle, president of Lund's Fisheries Jeff Kaelin, director of sustainability and government relations at Lund's Fisheries Ryan Mulvey, counsel with the Cause of Action Institute Erica Fuller, senior counsel with the Conservation…

People in this episode

Host: Matthew S. Schwartz

Guests: Wayne Reichle, Jeff Kaelin, Ryan Mulvey, Erica Fuller, Leif Axelsson, Greg Stohr

Topics covered

• fishing industry
• federal regulation
• Chevron doctrine
• agency power
• legal challenges
• environmental law

Keywords

• Chevron doctrine
• fishing regulations
• federal agencies
• legal authority
• environmental policy

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Lund's Fisheries, Cause of Action Institute, Conservation Law Foundation, Bloomberg News

Places: Dyrsten

More episodes of UnCommon Law

• Justice Transformed: When DOJ Norms Disappear · May 6, 2026 · 27 min
• Justice Transformed: Trailer · April 13, 2026 · 3 min
• 5. Did Schoolhouse Rock Lie to Us? · August 20, 2025 · 37 min
• 4. Chevron is Dead. Is the Administrative State Still Alive? · August 13, 2025 · 32 min
• 3. Loper Bright: How a Little Boat Made Big Waves · May 28, 2025 · 33 min
• 1. Deadly Haze: How an Invisible Bubble of Pollution Changed the Way Government Regulates Everything · March 5, 2025 · 29 min