Feature Film #44 -- All This from a Slice of Gabagool

Feature Film #44 -- All This from a Slice of Gabagool

June 3, 2026 · 1h 22m · Episode 83

About this episode

A baseball star returns home to find his town drained of joy and must unite rival deli families to stop a demonic threat.

In a world where a Cleveland sandwich shop is the frontline defense against the underworld, one man must choose between his legacy on the baseball diamond and his shift at the deli. Welcome to the highly anticipated official sequel to The Hustle Is Weird! Josh is a rising Minor League baseball star who just tied the home run record. He returns home to Mentor, Ohio for the All-Star break, eagerly anticipating a relaxing week filled with Paulie's famous sandwiches . But instead of a triumphant homecoming, Josh finds a muted, quiet town that has been mysteriously drained of all its joy, passion, and flavor. The culprit is their old demonic nemesis, Juliano, who is siphoning the town's energy using cursed jars of "Pre-Minced Garlic" distributed by a sinister front company called 666 Meat, Cheese, and More. To stop the demonic apocalypse from fully consuming the town, Josh and Paulie must reunite the four rival Italian deli families using the "Imperial Gabagool"—a sacred, well-aged hunk of cured meat that invokes a powerful Smoked Meat Pact. Armed with holy baseball bats, garlic ropes, and pockets full of passionately delicious gabagool, the deli gang must crash…

More episodes of Beer Me That Movie

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Beer Me That Movie podcast page.