Lindsay Clancy Juror Speaks — Holdout Story Gets Even Stranger | Crime Talk

Lindsay Clancy Juror Speaks — Holdout Story Gets Even Stranger | Crime Talk

From Crime Talk with Scott Reisch by R. Scott Reisch

September 10, 2026 · 24 min

About this episode

A juror from the Lindsay Clancy case discusses the holdout's strange behavior during deliberations and raises questions about the jury's deadlock.

Another Lindsay Clancy juror is breaking his silence — and what he says about the lone holdout is raising even more questions about how the jury ended up deadlocked 11-to-1. Juror Nick Dargie says he repeatedly asked the holdout to identify the evidence supporting his position and claims he never received a clear answer. He also describes a bizarre moment involving an exercise band during deliberations. We break down what these new allegations mean, the other side of the argument, and why the holdout's own version of events remains the one we still have not heard. Also today on Crime Talk: • One year after the assassination of Charlie Kirk, where the criminal case against Tyler Robinson stands today • A major competency ruling in the Ohio "House of Horrors" case • A Bitcoin kidnapping and robbery scheme ends with a 15-year federal sentence • A nearly 30-year-old "Lake Man" cold case gets a major break • Legal History • Legal Quote • And a Florida Waffle House incident involving underwear, alcohol… and flying beef sticks in today's Dumb Criminal Subscribe to Crime Talk for daily coverage of the biggest criminal cases, courtroom developments, trials and legal news. #LindsayClancy…

People in this episode

Host: R. Scott Reisch

Guest: Nick Dargie

Topics covered

Keywords

More episodes of Crime Talk with Scott Reisch

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Crime Talk with Scott Reisch podcast page.