Lindsay Clancy Jury DEADLOCKED Again — Mistrial Next?

Lindsay Clancy Jury DEADLOCKED Again — Mistrial Next?

From Crime Talk with Scott Reisch by R. Scott Reisch

September 3, 2026 · 19 min

About this episode

Scott Reisch discusses the deadlocked jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial and the implications of a potential mistrial.

The Lindsay Clancy jury remains DEADLOCKED. After more than 34 hours of deliberations and two separate notices that jurors cannot reach a unanimous decision, Judge William Sullivan has already delivered the powerful Tuey-Rodriguez — or "dynamite" — instruction. Now the question is: What happens if the jury says they still cannot agree? Could the Lindsay Clancy trial end in a mistrial? Scott Reisch breaks down where the case stands, what a hung jury would mean, and whether prosecutors could try Lindsay Clancy all over again. Also on today's Crime Talk: • Lori Vallow Daybell gets a date before the Idaho Supreme Court in her appeal. • Barry Morphew faces major new restrictions after the judge sees video from the alleged Denver hit-and-run incident. • A Florida woman dubbed the alleged "Black Widow" is accused of poisoning a man she met through a dating app. • More Other Cases making headlines. • Legal History and the Legal Quote of the Day. • And an unforgettable Florida man earns our Dumb Criminal of the Day after allegedly telling a police officer: "I want to fight you." Going on a blind date or meeting someone online? Don't commit dating malpractice. Check them out at…

People in this episode

Host: Scott Reisch

Topics covered

Keywords

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Crime Talk, Idaho Supreme Court, CrimeTalkSearch.com

More episodes of Crime Talk with Scott Reisch

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Crime Talk with Scott Reisch podcast page.