About this episode

Matthew Cutolo discusses his role as Executive Pastry Chef at Gargiulo's Restaurant and the legacy of Italian-American cuisine.

Matthew Cutolo is the Executive Pastry Chef and third-generation chef at Gargiulo's Restaurant, a Coney Island institution since 1907. He helps oversee both front and back of house, preserving rare Italian-American dishes seldom found elsewhere. A sought-after culinary voice, Cutolo has been featured on the Today Show, CBS's The Dish, The New York Times, NBC New York, PIX11, and Fox's Good Day NY. Beyond the kitchen, he creates content championing classic Italian traditions and is now building his own digital platform dedicated to his culinary philosophy, signature recipes, and entrepreneurial ventures, establishing himself as a culinary entrepreneur for the next generation of food lovers. Chef Matthew Cutolo was halfway through an accounting degree when his uncle called and asked one question — you coming to work when you're done? That was it. No speech, no pitch. He's been in the kitchen at Gargiulo's ever since, third generation now, running a Coney Island restaurant his family's had since 1965 in a building that's been slinging Italian food since 1907. A hundred and nineteen years in one spot. I've had guys work under me for years before I'd actually show them anything real —…

More episodes of Fell Into Food Podcast

• Nicole Bentler: Pocono Maple, Before The Syrup · August 31, 2026 · 34 min
• Jason Olinik: Discernment / The Dining Room Disagrees · August 24, 2026 · 43 min
• Jeff Tonidandel & Jamie Brown Making Charlotte the “City of Hospitality” · August 17, 2026 · 47 min

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Fell Into Food Podcast podcast page.