The Don Studey Green Hollow Case That Won't Die
About this episode
Bob Motta shares his wild firsthand account of investigating the Green Hollow case involving Don Studey.
Bob Motta has been sitting on this story for three years. He's telling it here first — and it's one of the wildest firsthand accounts in true crime. The criminal defense attorney drove to Green Hollow in the middle of the night, infiltrated an FBI dig in a rental car that looked like a cop cruiser, went viral on TikTok while local deputies watched his content in real time, and spent sixteen months investigating the allegations that Don Studey was the Green Hollow Killer. He spent over a hundred hours on the phone with Lucy Studey-McKiddy vetting her claims. He got waved past a federal checkpoint. He scaled a dirt wall to reach the fence line. He heard the feds working in the area Lucy described. A deputy told him Gacy's first victim was from Green Hollow and related to the Studeys — something Lucy never mentioned despite Bob talking about Gacy constantly. In the nearby towns, everyone had a story. The mayor invited him to dinner. Locals shared firsthand accounts of Don Studey — the boogeyman their parents had warned them about. Bob uncovered alleged mob connections and an unsolved robbery. Lucy's sister Susan spent the investigation drunk-texting that it was all a lie. Retired…
More episodes of Hidden Killers Live! Daily True Crime News & Breakdowns
- Don Studey's Own Daughters Can't Agree on Green Hollow
- The Secrets Green Hollow Kept About Don Studey for Decades
- What Was Found on Don Studey's Green Hollow Fence Line
- Reiner, D4vd, Duggar: Behavioral Analysis of Three Active Cases
- Joseph and Kendra Duggar: Charges in Two States Examined
- D4vd Case: Grand Juries, a Wiretap, and Sealed Evidence
Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Hidden Killers Live! Daily True Crime News & Breakdowns podcast page.