Supernatural Music Extravaganza: A Mixtape 20 Years in the Making - Meet your co-hosts

Supernatural Music Extravaganza: A Mixtape 20 Years in the Making - Meet your co-hosts

From In Defense of Fandom by Sadie Witkowski

November 11, 2025 · 40 min

About this episode

The episode celebrates the 20th anniversary of Supernatural by exploring its musical legacy with interviews and discussions about iconic songs from the show.

Sadie, along with Denim-wrapped Nightmare's Berly and LA, kick off their massive 10-episode collaboration celebrating the 20th anniversary of Supernatural by diving into the show's iconic musical legacy. And yes, they interviewed over 20 people for this series because apparently they're all insane. The episode opens with a power move: Sadie asking Jared and Jensen about Supernatural's music at a convention panel (using Berly's name callout because Berly is a good friend who understands true J2 fandom priorities). From there, the hosts explore why music became so fundamental to the show's DNA—including Eric Kripke almost quitting over the network wanting to ditch classic rock for "current, exciting, young music." They discuss fan-favorite needle drops, with Death's entrance to "O Death" taking the crown as most mentioned, followed by the "Renegade" escape in "Night Shifter" and "Rooster" in "Folsom Prison Blues." There's also a moment of silence for all the needle drops lost to streaming music licensing (RIP "Don't Fear the Reaper" in the Faith episode). The hosts break down the convention music experience—Saturday Night Specials, Louden Swain as the house band, Jason Manns, and…

More episodes of In Defense of Fandom

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the In Defense of Fandom podcast page.