Supernatural Music Extravaganza: Finding Their Voices - Briana Buckmaster & Lisa Berry

Supernatural Music Extravaganza: Finding Their Voices - Briana Buckmaster & Lisa Berry

December 26, 2025 · 50 min

About this episode

Briana Buckmaster and Lisa Berry share their journeys of overcoming vocal insecurities and finding their voices in the music industry.

Welcome back to another installment of the Denim-wrapped Nightmares and In Defense of Fandom collaboration, Supernatural Music Extravaganza! What happens when two powerhouse voices (who spent years thinking they weren't good enough) finally find their people? Pure magic, that's what. Briana Buckmaster and Lisa Berry take us back to a fateful train ride from a Stage West audition where they bonded over being told their alto, bluesy, rock voices didn't fit the "belt to an E, ingenue" sound that musical theater demanded. Spoiler: the industry was wrong, and Saturday Night Special proved it. From Bri's traumatic vocal node saga (thanks, restaurant work and Beauty and the Beast) to Lisa spending a decade not singing at all before landing Death on Supernatural, these two get real about vocal insecurity, jet lag voice loss, and why Jason Manns is everyone's musical fairy godfather. There's the story of how Phil Sgriccia turned Lisa's trailer recording of "O Death" into the iconic season 11 trailer, why steroid shots are a musical theater thing (opera singers just cancel, apparently), and how Lisa manifested becoming Death through sheer fan theory energy. Plus: why Louden Swain won't let…

More episodes of In Defense of Fandom

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the In Defense of Fandom podcast page.