Overcoming evolution | Subrina Smith, Keith Frankish, Simon Baron-Cohen

About this episode

A debate on the implications and validity of evolutionary psychology in understanding human behavior.

Is evolutionary psychology merely a way of excusing outdated behaviours? Is it instead culture which really defines how we behave? As with the animal kingdom, we see human behaviour as the product of elemental drives to survive and reproduce. Evolutionary psychology has taken this a stage further - seeing violence, social hierarchy, and sexual promiscuity as a product of evolutionary drives. But might this be a misleading and dangerous approach? Murder rates have fallen seventy-fold since the Middle Ages, and across the globe birth rates are a fraction of what they were a hundred years ago. Fathers are actively involved in child care and we've radically changed our outlook on social issues like gender identity - suggesting ideas and culture drive behaviour rather than evolution. Should we conclude that evolutionary psychology is a blind alley with no predictive power? Are we capable of overcoming behavioural traits and therefore wholly responsible for our actions? Or is evolution an inescapable force and behavioural change a result of altered circumstances while our core nature remains identical? Critic of evolutionary psychology Subrena E. Smith, philosopher of mind Keith…

People in this episode

Host: Güneş Taylor

Guests: Subrina E. Smith, Keith Frankish, Simon Baron-Cohen

Topics covered

• evolutionary psychology
• human behavior
• culture
• violence
• gender identity
• responsibility

Keywords

• evolutionary psychology
• human behavior
• cultural influence
• social issues
• gender identity
• violence
• responsibility

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: IAI

More episodes of Philosophy For Our Times

• The return of idealism | James Tartaglia · June 9, 2026 · 28 min
• Reimagining the right | Richard Tice · June 2, 2026 · 30 min
• Is philosophy becoming irrelevant? | Mary Midgley · May 26, 2026 · 28 min
• Who's afraid of gender? | Judith Butler · May 19, 2026 · 41 min
• Human perception is imagination | Nadine Dijkstra · May 12, 2026 · 14 min
• The brain filters consciousness | Alex Gomez-Marin · May 5, 2026 · 30 min