The Season 2 Finale: Growth, Cringe, and The True Crime Story Never Told

The Season 2 Finale: Growth, Cringe, and The True Crime Story Never Told

May 26, 2026 · 37 min · Season 2 · Episode 24

About this episode

In the Season 2 finale, Cole shares a chilling true crime story from his past while reflecting on the podcast's growth over 50 episodes.

50 episodes. A full year of chaos, dad gripes, and hyper-fixation deep dives. We have officially reached the Season 2 finale of The Dad Voice, and we’re closing things out by taking a look at where we started, where we’re going, and delivering on a long-awaited promise. A while back, a short clip went viral where Cole mentioned a horrific event from his past but never got to tell the full story. Tonight, he finally opens up. Cole breaks down the chilling reality of the fate of his neighbor who went missing in July 2013 and was tragically discovered to have been murdered by her boyfriend, Cole discusses what it was like living right next to that environment, the shock of the discovery, and his experience being interviewed by Fox News the morning after the arrest. Before things get too heavy, we take a walk down memory lane to react to our cringey, awkward Episode 1. We look at how our production, audio, and chemistry have evolved over 50 episodes, and we pull back the curtain on our massive plans for Season 3. In this episode: The Promise Fulfilled: Cole’s true story about his former neighbor, Angelique Sylvester. The Flashback: Reacting to the technical glitches and awkwardness…

People in this episode

Host: Cole

Topics covered

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Fox News

More episodes of The Dad Voice Podcast

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the The Dad Voice Podcast podcast page.