About this episode

Sammi Cohen discusses the $24 million lawsuit between Van Leeuwen and Rebel Creamery over trade dress infringement in ice cream packaging.

A federal judge just ordered an ice cream company to hand over nearly $24 million because their pint looked a little too much like someone else's. Today, Sammi breaks down the case of Van Leeuwen versus Rebel Creamery, a lawsuit that is about way more than ice cream. She explains how Van Leeuwen's pastel packaging, designed by the firm Pentagram in 2016, became one of the most valuable assets in the company's business and helped drive a nearly 50% jump in sales velocity. Then she unpacks how keto ice cream brand Rebel launched with strikingly similar packaging, despite a buyer warning them beforehand that it looked like a ripoff. Sammi digs into the legal concept of trade dress, which protects the overall look and feel of a product rather than any single design element, and explains why the court sided with Van Leeuwen. She also covers the idea of "reverse confusion," why Rebel's missing design paperwork sank their case, and how the judge's finding of bad faith unlocked a massive damages award under the Lanham Act. Finally, Sammi shares why this case matters for every founder and brand builder today: in an age where AI can replicate any aesthetic instantly, the real competitive…

People in this episode

Host: Sammi Cohen

Topics covered

• ice cream lawsuit
• trade dress
• branding
• legal concepts
• reverse confusion
• business strategy

Keywords

• ice cream lawsuit
• Van Leeuwen
• Rebel Creamery
• trade dress
• branding
• Pentagram
• Lanham Act
• reverse confusion
• business strategy

Sponsors

Mercury

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Van Leeuwen, Rebel Creamery, Pentagram, Lanham Act

More episodes of Social Currency with Sammi Cohen

• Dan Clancy (Twitch) on Live Streaming Community, Creator Monetization and the Future of AI · September 9, 2026 · 1h 9m
• Chili's Comeback, Decoded · August 25, 2026 · 17 min
• Ankur Jain (Bilt) on the AI Commerce Race, Celebrity Rent Day Collabs and Neighborhood Concierge · August 18, 2026 · 56 min
• Everlane, Reformation and the Cracks in "Ethical Fashion" · August 11, 2026 · 15 min
• Raina Moskowitz (The Knot) on the Wedding Economy, the Taylor Swift Effect and AI Planning · August 4, 2026 · 60 min
• Kory Marchisotto (e.l.f. Beauty) on Acquiring Rhode, Building a Billion-Dollar Brand and Responding When Campaigns Don’t Land · July 28, 2026 · 1h 6m

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Social Currency with Sammi Cohen podcast page.