CASE 0519: We're Gonna Need A Bigger Bottle

About this episode

In the season finale, the hosts discuss the Jaws Amity Island Red Blend while diving into topics like sharks, cinema history, and humorous anecdotes.

DEFENDANT: Bruce EVIDENCE: Jaws Amity Island Red Blend SCENE OF THE CRIME: A Beach Near You -- Hey friend — welcome to the season finale of True Crimes Against Wine, where we drank a Jaws-labeled Napa red and then took a deep dive into sharks, sea-snail sex, and why Spielberg’s technical failures made cinema history. We’re sipping a 55% Petit Syrah blend with Merlot, Cabernet and a cheeky 5% Aligoté (yes, Aligoté!), talking oak and cinnamon, and wondering whether the grape’s fruit-forward nose would match the surprisingly soft, dry sip. We reminisce about our first Jaws experiences, dissect the iconic two-note theme (you know the one), and praise the film’s suspenseful genius born from broken mechanical sharks. There are quiz rounds, outfit descriptions (I’m the poodle in a fur coat — clearly), and a whole lot of drunk rambling about bull sharks, the USS Indianapolis, friendship foam, and sea-creature mating rituals that somehow led us to discuss third nipples and the best mid-’70s blazers. Classic season finale energy. If you love movie lore, bad-but-fun wine labels, and unfiltered sidebar chaos, this episode is a salty, sunburned treat. Grab something chilled (or cellar-temp)…

People in this episode

Hosts: Judge Topher, Judge Rachel

Topics covered

• wine
• movies
• sharks
• cinema history
• humor
• season finale

Keywords

• Jaws
• wine
• sharks
• Napa
• season finale
• humor
• cinema

Mentioned in this episode

Products: Jaws Amity Island Red Blend

Books & works: Jaws

Places: Napa, Amity Island, a Beach Near You

More episodes of True Crimes Against Wine

• People's Court Ep.08: Am I the Asshole for Ruining Three Relationships? · June 8, 2026 · 24 min
• Sidebar Ep.138:Wine-Fueled Nightmares: When Podcasts Keep You Up · June 1, 2026 · 10 min
• People's Court Ep.07: Hooking Up with a Taken Man — Who’s Really to Blame? · May 18, 2026 · 15 min
• CASE 0518: "After Her Gay Boyfriend Died..." · May 11, 2026 · 2h 28m
• People's Court Ep.06: Don't Poke the Mama Bear · May 4, 2026 · 14 min
• CASE 0516: Turtle Power! · April 27, 2026 · 1h 47m