A Pastor's Confession: Andy Reveals His Secret Addiction, Affair, and How God Met Him in His Mess

About this episode

Andy shares his journey of living a double life as a pastor struggling with addiction and infidelity, and how his confession led to freedom.

“I knew all the right things to say about Jesus, but I was living a completely different life when no one was looking.” That’s how Andy describes the reality of leading in the Church while quietly unraveling behind the scenes. Andy wasn’t just a Christian struggling in private—he was a pastor. He was preaching, leading, and helping others follow Jesus, all while hiding a life that didn’t match what people saw. Alcohol had a grip on him, but it didn’t stop there. What began as hidden drinking eventually gave way to deeper compromise, including an affair that would force everything into the light. In this episode, Andy walks through what it’s like to carry that kind of double life—not just the behaviors, but the weight of knowing the truth, teaching the truth, and still living in contradiction to it. There’s the pressure to maintain an image, the isolation that comes with secrecy, and the slow erosion of self that builds until there’s nowhere left to hide. He also brings us through the moment everything came to the light. The moment he thought would destroy him that actually became his door to freedom: his…

People in this episode

Host: Jon Seidl

Guest: Andy

Topics covered

• addiction
• confession
• faith
• mental health
• marriage
• spirituality

Keywords

• pastor
• addiction
• affair
• confession
• Christianity
• freedom
• mental health

More episodes of Confessions of a Christian Alcoholic with Jon Seidl

• How a Foster Mom Changed Her Mind on Addiction: Christina Dent's Life-Changing Realization · June 11, 2026 · 1h 20m
• From Pro Basketball Coach to Rock Bottom: Travis Blakeley's Story of Gospel-Centered Recovery and Restoration · June 3, 2026 · 1h 32m
• Hiding Addiction While Helping Others Recover: Jed Payne on the Reality of Relapse and Being Honest · May 27, 2026 · 1h 13m
• The Parts of You That Still Need Jesus: Trauma, Healing, and IFS with Kimberly Miller · May 20, 2026 · 1h 12m
• Has the Enneagram Duped Christians? Christina Wallace Reveals Some Shocking Details · May 13, 2026 · 1h 56m
• Saved from Sobriety: How Brett Smith Got Sober but Realized That Wasn't Enough · May 6, 2026 · 1h 31m