119. How to Negotiate a Senior Role When Your Manager is Brand New to the Team

119. How to Negotiate a Senior Role When Your Manager is Brand New to the Team

March 19, 2026 · 15 min · Season 3 · Episode 119

About this episode

Dani Tan discusses strategies for negotiating a senior role when your new manager is still settling in.

In episode 119, we're talking about how to negotiate a senior role when your manager is brand new to the team. You don't need to wait for your new manager to get settled before you start making your case. That window while they are forming their opinions, building their perspective, and figuring out who you are? That is your window. And it opens the moment they walk through the door. In this conversation, I break down the three-phase framework I use with my clients to help them stop waiting and start positioning, even in the middle of change and transition. In this episode, I cover: → Why a new manager is a window of opportunity, not a reason to pause → Phase 1: The Onboarding Trap and how to avoid it → Phase 2: Flip the Script — decoding the gap, making your knowledge visible, and picking your lane → A client story: from coming back from leave into chaos to making a business case for her promotion → Phase 3: Your Window — how to shape the narrative before the story gets written for you Key Takeaways: – Your new manager has no story about you yet — that is an advantage, not an obstacle – Waiting for them to settle in is the trap; position yourself during their onboarding, not…

More episodes of You're Overqualified Podcast - Career and Leadership Strategies for Women

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the You're Overqualified Podcast - Career and Leadership Strategies for Women podcast page.