About this episode

Tory Pachis discusses how Amica Insurance transformed its brand strategy and marketing approach to achieve significant brand awareness and customer loyalty.

Most insurance brands look the same, sound the same, and spend billions on ads to prove it. Amica decided to do the opposite. Daniel sits down with Tory Pachis (Executive Vice President & CMO of Amica Insurance) to break down how a 119-year-old, referral-only mutual insurer went from 2% unaided brand awareness to 70%…and why a jersey patch on the Boston Celtics was just the beginning. Tory shares how Amica built a sports marketing strategy around values alignment, not logo slaps, and why the Jason Tatum "Back to Zero" campaign became one of the most authentic brand stories in insurance. They get into why humor isn't the only tool in the insurance advertising toolbox, how to make the case for brand investment to a skeptical CFO, and what happens when your star athlete tears his Achilles the night after you sign the deal. They also dig into how Amica is thinking about AI and LLMs, and why a loyal customer base full of organic Reddit and Trustpilot reviews might be their biggest unfair advantage as search evolves. If you want to understand how challenger brands build modern relevance without abandoning their heritage, this episode is for you. Wrike brings structure, visibility, and…

People in this episode

Host: Daniel Murray

Guest: Tory Pachis

Topics covered

• brand strategy
• sports marketing
• insurance advertising
• AI in marketing
• customer loyalty
• brand awareness

Keywords

• brand awareness
• sports marketing
• insurance
• AI
• customer loyalty
• advertising strategy
• Jason Tatum
• Boston Celtics

Sponsors

Wrike

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Amica Insurance, Boston Celtics

More episodes of The Marketing Millennials

• 5 Webinar Tactics to Steal | Bathroom Break #110 · June 1, 2026 · 14 min
• The Affiliate Marketing Playbook with Cricket Treanor, Digital Marketing and Ecommerce at Patagonia | Ep. 420 · May 29, 2026 · 35 min
• Should You Pause Your Marketing on Holidays?| Bathroom Break #109 · May 25, 2026 · 13 min
• Guide to Marketing Complicated Products with Trey Ferro, CEO of Wag!, Ex-Spot Pet insurance | Ep. 418 · May 22, 2026 · 30 min
• The Truth About Your ICP with Hailey McDonald, VP of Revenue Marketing at Sprout Social | Ep. 417 · May 20, 2026 · 50 min
• The June 2026 Marketing Playbook | Bathroom Break #108 · May 18, 2026 · 11 min

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the The Marketing Millennials podcast page.