Elders or Priests? Why Catholic Authority Isn’t Earned—It’s Entrusted (#449)

About this episode

Greg Smith explores the differences between Catholic and Protestant church leadership, focusing on the concept of authority being entrusted rather than earned.

In the New Testament, Paul gives clear qualifications for presbyteroi—elders—who must be the husband of one wife, manage their household well, and hold fast to sound doctrine. When Greg was a Protestant pastor, that seemed to describe exactly what church leadership should look like under sola scriptura. So where do Catholic priests come from? In this first part of a two-episode series, Greg tackles that question head-on with honesty and charity, drawing from Scripture, the early Church Fathers, and Graham Greene’s unforgettable “whiskey priest” in The Power and the Glory. He explains the crucial difference: Protestant leadership tends to be earned by personal qualifications, while Catholic priestly authority is entrusted by Christ through apostolic succession—so that even a flawed priest can still give us Christ Himself acting in persona Christi. If you’ve ever wondered why the priesthood looks so different from what you grew up with, this episode will give you fresh eyes, real hope, and a deeper love for the Church. (Part 2 drops next: Why Only Men?) SUPPORT THIS SHOW Considering Catholicism is 100% listener-supported. If this podcast has helped you on your journey, please…

People in this episode

Host: Greg Smith

Topics covered

• Catholic authority
• Protestant leadership
• apostolic succession
• church leadership
• New Testament
• early Church Fathers

Keywords

• Catholicism
• priesthood
• elders
• authority
• Protestantism
• apostolic succession
• church leadership

Mentioned in this episode

Books & works: The Power and the Glory

More episodes of Considering Catholicism

• Development of Doctrine in Real Time: Live Debates and Clear Boundaries (#462) · June 11, 2026 · 42 min
• What Development of Doctrine Really Is (And Isn’t) (#461) · June 8, 2026 · 33 min
• Mary in the Dock, part 3: Is Mary the New Eve? (#460) · June 4, 2026 · 32 min
• Mary in the Dock, Part 2: Mother of God — Blasphemy or Biblical Truth? (#459) · June 1, 2026 · 30 min
• Mary in the Dock, Part 1: Is Devotion to Her Idolatry? (#458) · May 29, 2026 · 35 min
• Mystery, Magic, and the Search for Meaning (#464) · May 26, 2026 · 42 min